Counterargument vs Paradox - What's the difference?
counterargument | paradox |
A self-contradictory statement, which can only be true if it is false, and vice versa.
* {{quote-book, 1962, Abraham Wolf, Textbook of Logic, page=255
, passage=According to one version of an ancient paradox , an Athenian is supposed to say "I am a liar." It is then argued that if the statement is true, then he is telling the truth, and is therefore not a liar
A counterintuitive conclusion or outcome.
* 1983 May 21, (Ronald Reagan), "",
A claim that two apparently contradictory ideas are true.(jump)
* {{quote-book, 1879, ,
, passage=How quaint the ways of Paradox ! / At common sense she gaily mocks! / Though counting in the usual way years twenty-one I've been alive, / Yet reck'ning by my natal day, / Yet reck'ning by my natal day, / I am a little boy of five!}}
A person or thing having contradictory properties.
* {{quote-book, 1999, Virginia Henley, A Year and a Day
, passage=You are a paradox of bitch and angel.}}
An unanswerable question or difficult puzzle, particularly one which leads to a deeper truth.
* {{quote-book, 1994, James Joseph Pirkl, Transgenerational Design, page=3
, passage=And only by dismantling our preconceptions of age can we be free to understand the paradox : How young are the old?}}
(obsolete) A statement which is difficult to believe, or which goes against general belief.
* {{quote-book, 1594, William Shakespeare, The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark, section=
, passage=Ay, truly; for the power of beauty will sooner / transform honesty from what it is to a bawd than the / force of honesty can translate beauty into his / likeness: this was sometime a paradox , but now the / time gives it proof. }}
* 1615 , Ralph Hamor, A True Discourse of the Present State of Virginia , Richmond 1957, p. 3
(uncountable) The use of counterintuitive or contradictory statements (paradoxes) in speech or writing.
* {{quote-book, 1906, (Richard Holt Hutton), Brief Literary Criticisms, page=40
, passage=The need for paradox is no doubt rooted deep in the very nature of the use we make of language. }}
(uncountable, philosophy) A state in which one is logically compelled to contradict oneself.
* {{quote-book, 1866, Edward Poste, Aristotle on Fallacies, Or, The Sophistici Elenchi, page=43
, passage=Thus, like modern disputants, they aimed either to confute the respondent or to land him in paradox . }}
(uncountable, psychotherapy) The practice of giving instructions that are opposed to the therapist's actual intent, with the intention that the client will disobey or be unable to obey.(jump)
* {{quote-book, 1988, Martin Lakin, Ethical Issues in the Psychotherapies, page=103
, passage=Defiance-based paradox is employed so that the family will actively oppose and deliberately sabotage the prescription. }}
As nouns the difference between counterargument and paradox
is that counterargument is an argument that is opposed to another argument while paradox is paradox.counterargument
English
(wikipedia counterargument)paradox
English
(wikipedia paradox)Noun
(es)- "This sentence is false" is a paradox .
citation
- It is an interesting paradox that drinking a lot of water can often make you feel thirsty.
- The most fundamental paradox is that if we're never to use force, we must be prepared to use it and to use it successfully.
- Not having a fashion is a fashion; that's a paradox .
The Complete Plays of Gilbert and Sullivan], year_published=1941, chapter=[[w:The Pirates of Penzance, The Pirates of Penzance]
- He is a paradox ; you would not expect him in that political party.
citation
citation
- they contended to make that Maxim'', that there is no faith to be held with Infidels, a meere and absurd ''Paradox [...].
citation
citation
citation
Usage notes
* A statement which contradicts itself in this fashion is a paradox; two statements which contradict each other are an antinomy. * This use may be considered incorrect or inexact. ** {{quote-news, 1995, January 14, Ian Stewart,Paradox of the Spheres, New Scientist , passage=Banach and Tarski's theorem (commonly known as the Banach-Tarski paradox, though it is not a true paradox, being counterintuitive rather than self-contradictory) ** {{quote-book, 1998, , Encyclopedia of Applied Physics
citation, passage=It is not a true paradox, merely highly nonintuitive behavior, if one accepts the realistic and local assumptions of EPR., i2=**:}} * This use may be considered incorrect or inexact. ** {{quote-book, 1917, George Crabb,
Crabb's English Synonymes, chapter=ENIGMA, PARADOX, RIDDLE, edition=Centennial ed. , passage=An enigma, therefore, is not a paradox, but a paradox, not being intelligible, may seem like an enigma. , i2=**:}}